Higher Deductible vs. Higher Premiums: Questions to Ask Yourself When Getting Home Insurance

Higher Deductible vs. Higher Premiums: Questions to Ask Yourself When Getting Home Insurance

  • Heather Smith
  • 11/21/24

When it comes to home insurance, there are a number of different options and it can be hard to figure out what type of plan would work best for you. For example, is it better to go for a plan with a large deductible and lower premiums, or a plan with a lower deductible and higher premiums?

recent article from realtor.com answered common questions to ask yourself when evaluating home insurance plans, including:

  • Where do you live? Location plays a huge role in insurance pricing and what kind of plan you should opt for. For example, if you live in an area where there’s a high likelihood of natural disasters—like hurricanes or wildflowers—you might opt to pay the higher premium, knowing that there’s a likelihood that you may have to file a claim. However, if you live in an area that’s not prone to natural disasters, you might opt for a plan with a higher deductible and lower monthly premiums.
  • Can I afford the deductible? Before you commit to an insurance plan, it’s important to look at the deductible and make sure that, in the event that you need to file a claim, you can cover the deductible. While it might be tempting to go with a high deductible/low premium plan which can save money on a monthly basis, you could find yourself regretting that decision if you can’t cover the cost of the deductible when your home incurs damages.
  • Can you switch later? If you’re stressed about what plan to go with, check in with your lender to see if it’s possible to switch things up later. For example, if you’re strapped for cash at closing, you might opt for a high deductible plan for the first year, and then switch to a lower deductible plan after the first year is up.

Work With Heather

For most families, choosing a new home is the biggest financial decision they will ever make. There are many complicated decisions involved in choosing a home. As one of the top real estate professionals in the local market, I'll negotiate the best prices and terms for you and answer all of your questions as they arise.